NEW YORK (MainStreet) — When the hugely popular deal site Groupon announced it would go public earlier this year, many skeptics questioned whether high operating costs and the company’s sometimes tenuous relationship with retailers would make the site’s success short-lived. However, the more fundamental threat to Groupon’s business model and that of many other deal sites like it may be something that once seemed unthinkable: consumers could simply grow tired of all the bargains.
After the recession hit in late 2007, dozens of daily deal sites launched offering big discounts to the many consumers eagerly searching for ways to pinch pennies but still enjoy themselves. Suddenly, shoppers no longer had to rummage through multiple store circulars to find the right deal. Instead, these websites tailored offers to each shopper’s interests and location, and delivered these deals directly to their email inbox each morning.
- Your Local Mall Is Dying, and Back-to-School Shopping Won't Save It
- Telemarketers Still Call Us, and Other Top Consumer Complaints of 2013
- Target Heir Has 56,000 Custom Dresses for You Online
- Less Fertile Roosters Mean Higher Chicken Prices
- Last Year's Fashion Gets Second Life, and Seller Get the Rewards
While this formula has proved enticing enough for millions of subscribers to sign up for deal sites like Groupon and LivingSocial in the years since, several shopping experts speculate that these consumers will begin to experience a kind of deal burnout, if they haven’t already.
“There is definitely a risk of oversaturation with these daily deal programs,” said Kit Yarrow, a professor of psychology and marketing at Golden Gate University who specializes in consumer psychology research. “Consumers can develop an increasing tolerance to that sense of the thrill of a bargain, and eventually it just stops being thrilling.”
As Yarrow points out, many of the consumers she’s spoken with get eight to 10 deal-related emails per day. These consumers watch as their inboxes are flooded with flight promotions from Travelzoo, restaurant deals from Yelp, flash sales on clothing from Gilt Groupe and the infinite number of half-off teeth whitening offers that seem to be pushed out from all deal sites simultaneously.
Each of these deals is billed as a “significant discount” available for a “limited time only,” buzz words that are often used by marketers to compel the consumer to make an impulse buy. Yet it becomes increasingly difficult to convince consumers they need to make a purchase right then and there when they are offered countless limited-time bargains day after day, many of which resemble one another.
“That sense of urgency declines when you see the same deal on multiple sites or you notice each of the deal sites sends you the same kind of stuff over and over again,” said Michelle Madhok, an online shopping expert and founder of SheFinds.com.
And it’s not just the sense of urgency to make a purchase that changes, it’s also the level of expectation consumers have about what does and doesn’t constitute a good deal.
“I think consumers are approaching a new normalcy for bargains where they have come to accept the bargain as being the standard price, reducing their impact,” Yarrow said. “After all, if everything is always on sale, then the sale price becomes the new full price.”
In short, deals that consumers once would have considered too good to be true may now be seen as too common to be good.