NEW YORK (MainStreet) — There’s only so much Americans can accept before they feel taken advantage of and speak up. This year, perhaps more than any other in recent memory, proved to be the time when people around the country decided to speak up and say enough is enough.
During the previous 11 months, consumers took to the streets to fight price hikes, travelers mobilized online to retaliate against extra fees and job hunters petitioned for fairer hiring practices. Main Street Americans didn’t always win these fights – though occasionally, against all odds, they did. Yet, just by speaking up, these consumers and travelers and job hunters each sent a powerful message to many of the country’s biggest industries that Americans won’t just accept unfriendly policies. There may be a fight and yes, it will probably be a public relations disaster that could cause a business to lose customers and revenue.
Some of these battles were waged online through social media and blogs while others took place in protests and demonstrations in the street; a few did both. One fight involved tens of thousands of frustrated customers, another only needed a single household to make an impact. Each will hopefully serve as the ultimate deterrent against consumer unfriendly business decisions in 2012 and beyond.
Bank Transfer Day
Big banks have been toying with new fees ever since the Dodd-Frank financial reform package – and the Durbin amendment in particular – was approved, cutting into their revenue from swipe fees, but the banks may have gone one step too far this summer when some began to charge a monthly debit card usage fee. Wells Fargo began testing a $3 fee in several states in August and Bank of America later followed suit by proposing a $5 monthly fee.
In another year, customers of these banks might have just grudgingly accepted the possibility of new fees, but instead something strange happened. Consumers began to mobilize online and signed up to be part of Bank Transfer Day, a kind of targeted uprising against the major financial institutions. More than 80,000 people around the country pledged to transfer their money out of their big bank and into a credit union on Nov. 5.
Sure enough, some 40,000 people did actually open up accounts with credit unions that day and 650,000 did so in the month leading up to it as credit unions gained more attention in the national media. Faced with a mass exodus, banks did something unusual and canceled their new debit card fees. One after another, SunTrust, Wells Fargo, Chase and finally even Bank of America did away with plans for the extra charge.
Who won: There’s no doubt that consumers won out in the short-term by forcing banks to get rid of the fee, but in the long-term it’s a little less clear. Industry analysts predict that banks will rely on other subtler ways to increase fees for the consumer if need be, and the big banks could shutter some branches and staff, effectively giving customers poorer service. Beyond that, one can argue that the purpose of Bank Transfer Day was greater than debit card fees – it was about reinvesting in local institutions rather than big businesses that some view as corrupt. By that standard, supporters of this movement won’t truly have won until more Americans switch their money around as well.
Netflix Price Hike
Netflix went from being one of the most beloved businesses to public enemy #1 this summer when it announced a 60% price hike for those who stream movies and rent DVDs each month. The news caused countless Netflix customers to take to Twitter, Facebook and other social networking platforms and complain about the business’ decision. Many promised to quit the service when the changes took effect and Netflix itself predicted it would lose as many as 1 million subscribers as a result.
The situation only worsened when Netflix revealed two months later that it planned to spin off its DVD-by-mail division completely into a new business entity called Qwikster. The change would have required consumers with DVD and streaming subscriptions to manage two separate accounts on two distinct websites, an inconvenience that did not go unnoticed by users. After constant complaints online from consumers – not to mention the hit to the company’s stock – Netflix decided to scrap Qwikster the following month and go back to business as usual, almost.
Who won: In truth, neither Netflix nor the consumers really won this fight, at least not yet. Yes, Netflix users don’t have to worry about managing multiple accounts, but the price hike that really bothered them in the beginning is still in effect. Meanwhile, even though Netflix retains the vast majority of its customer base and an increased revenue stream from the price hike, its brand remains tarnished and its stock has dropped to its lowest point all year.
Baggage Fees for Military Personnel
No airline racks up more money from baggage fees than Delta, but when a pair of soldiers complained in a video on YouTube that their unit of about 30 people had been charged nearly $3,000 in total to check in all their luggage, Delta found itself in an instant public relations disaster. The video of returning soldiers upset about having to fork over hundreds of dollars each out of pocket for carrying extra luggage the military authorized them to bring forced Delta to respond.
Delta overhauled its baggage policy for military personnel, upping the number of bags that can be checked to four when flying coach and five when flying in first class and business. Other airlines like AirTran went one step further and waived all baggage fees for military members.
Who won: Without a doubt, the soldiers came out on top in this fight. That said, Delta helped itself by resolving the situation in a single day rather than letting it drag out. Other businesses could learn from this approach.